From Payment Struggles to $26B Powerhouse: Is Affirm the Future of Shopping—or a Risky Bet?

Affirm started as a simple idea: let people buy things now and pay later, without the surprise fees credit cards love to hide. For years, the company burned cash trying to prove this "Buy Now Pay Later" (BNPL) model could actually make money.

But something changed. In their latest quarter, Affirm's revenue jumped 32% to $876 million. Even better? They finally turned a profit—20 cents per share after years of losses. The company now processes over $10 billion in purchases every quarter, working with 377,000 stores and 23 million shoppers. Their in-store payment volume exploded 187%, and active cardholders nearly doubled to 2.3 million.

Here's the twist: while the business is working, the stock trades at $78 with analyst targets ranging from $58 to $97. Some see the next Visa. Others see a house of cards one recession away from collapse.

Over 4 million professionals start their day with Morning Brew—because business news doesn’t have to be boring.

Each daily email breaks down the biggest stories in business, tech, and finance with clarity, wit, and relevance—so you're not just informed, you're actually interested.

Whether you’re leading meetings or just trying to keep up, Morning Brew helps you talk the talk without digging through social media or jargon-packed articles. And odds are, it’s already sitting in your coworker’s inbox—so you’ll have plenty to chat about.

It’s 100% free and takes less than 15 seconds to sign up, so try it today and see how Morning Brew is transforming business media for the better.

Check it out

Affirm's story isn't just about payment technology—it's about whether young shoppers will abandon credit cards forever.

The big question: Is this the smartest growth play in fintech—or an overpriced stock ignoring massive risks?

Parkev Tatevosian (CFA, Finance Professor — Strong Buy): "This is a two-sided network like Visa. Merchants and consumers both grew 24% for six consecutive quarters of accelerating growth. They nearly doubled transaction volume while keeping staff flat—revenue per employee now exceeds $1.5 million. That's real operating leverage."

River1 Asset Management (Professional Fund — Staying Out): "The business works, but $78 is too expensive. We calculate fair value at $60 using a 30x PE on 2027 earnings of $2 per share. At current prices, there's very little room for error when facing two massive risks: recession and regulation."

Apollonian Research (PhD Economics — Sell): "The market prices in near-perfect execution. Major threats aren't adequately priced: escalating competition from PayPal and Apple, dangerous merchant concentration, and growing credit risk as US consumer debt hits records. Too little margin of safety."

The Asian Investor (30K Followers, Fintech Specialist — Strong Buy): "Everyone's underestimating the GAAP profitability milestone. The market hasn't repriced this yet. With Fed rate cuts coming, I see multiple expansion potential. Forward earnings revisions will drive this higher—there's real valuation upside left."

Stone Fox Capital (CFA, RIA — Sell): "New cost headwinds are crushing margins. JPMorgan now charges fintechs for data access—a direct hit to profitability. Add ongoing dilution from stock compensation, and these 'profits' look a lot less impressive. Pass at current valuation."

The J Thesis (Derivatives Expert, 10+ Years — Buy, $97 Target): "29% upside from here. The 33% revenue growth and 43% GMV growth justify the premium valuation. BNPL momentum is real, and Affirm leads the category. Yes, leverage is high and margins trail peers, but execution will overcome this."

Jack Elias (Tech Investor — Hold): "Solid quarter, but three concerns keep me neutral: regulatory risk from targeting vulnerable borrowers, heavy Amazon dependence, and reliance on credit markets. They're expanding into video games, which diversifies, but one regulatory crackdown changes everything."

Stockmindsweb (Comprehensive Analyst — Bullish): "Wall Street consensus is buy with a $95 target. Free cash flow per share jumped 87% to $1.76. Yes, they haven't faced a complete credit cycle, but the 45.97% gross margin and 18.66% free cash flow margin show a sustainable model. The CFPB risk exists but hasn't materialized."

Anonymous Retail Investor (Holding, Nervous): "I use Affirm myself—it's honestly better than my credit card. But that 8.5% default rate versus 2% at JP Morgan scares me. If we hit recession and those loan buyers disappear, what happens? I'm keeping my position small until we see how they handle tough times."

Julia Ostian (Market Analyst, YouTube — Buy Despite Overvaluation): "It's the only overvalued stock I'm buying. The Google partnership is huge—instant distribution to millions. Card GMV surged 132% year-over-year. Yes, Klarna and PayPal compete, but Affirm's merchant ecosystem with Shopify opening Western Europe creates a real moat."

Julian Lin (36K Followers, Growth Stock Leader — Hold, Take Profits): "Impressed by growth, but valuation reflects peak optimism. Apple Pay Later launched, PayPal's pushing hard, and every bank wants this business. Growth will decelerate, and this is cyclical. Take profits now, wait for $58-60 range to reload."

Ahmed Abdelazim (Product Focus — Buy): "Everyone misses the sticky product moat. Once merchants integrate and consumers adopt, switching costs are real. The network effect builds customer lifetime value through cross-selling—the Affirm card at 0% APR increases LTV significantly. This creates sustainable profitability."

Juxtaposed Ideas (14.7K Followers, Full-Time Analyst — Buy on Dips): "The operating inflection proved BNPL bears wrong. Delinquency trends well, cross-selling to the card works, and the business model is validated. That said, we're overbought short-term. Wait for a tactical dip, then add aggressively."

The Business:

Valuation:

Catalysts:

Risks:

I see Affirm as a legitimate business at a questionable price.

The bull case is real: proven profitability, explosive growth metrics, genuine product-market fit, and major partnerships positioning them for international scale. The two-sided network effect is building.

The bear case is equally valid: expensive at 40x forward earnings, never tested in downturn, rising competition from tech giants, regulatory crosshairs, and a credit model dependent on loan buyers who could vanish in crisis.

My stance:

Bottom line: Affirm could be the next Visa—or the poster child for overpaying for growth. The business works, but the price demands perfection.