Every Expert Agrees CrowdStrike Is Essential—So Why Are Half of Them Saying Sell at $470?

CrowdStrike built its reputation on protecting companies from hackers. Its cloud-based Falcon platform became the gold standard, growing revenue 68% annually over a decade and reaching $1.17 billion in quarterly sales.

Then came July 2024. A buggy software update crashed 8.5 million Windows computers worldwide—grounding flights, shutting hospitals, freezing retailers. Delta Airlines alone lost over $500 million. The "cybersecurity leader" had accidentally created the very chaos it promises to prevent.

Yet here's what's wild: the stock recovered. CrowdStrike now trades at $470 with a forward P/E of 125x—five times higher than most software companies. Bulls see an AI-powered future where every digital agent needs a security guard. Bears see a bloated valuation one misstep away from collapse. Even Morgan Stanley, after raising their target, downgraded the stock, saying it's "fully valued."

Before we move ahead, we would like to thank our sponsor for this edition

As with any digital ad campaign, the important thing is to reach streaming audiences who will convert. To that end, Roku’s self-service Ads Manager stands ready with powerful segmentation and targeting options. After all, you know your customers, and we know our streaming audience.

Worried it’s too late to spin up new Black Friday creative? With Roku Ads Manager, you can easily import and augment existing creative assets from your social channels. We also have AI-assisted upscaling, so every ad is primed for CTV.

Once you’ve done this, then you can easily set up A/B tests to flight different creative variants and Black Friday offers. If you’re a Shopify brand, you can even run shoppable ads directly on-screen so viewers can purchase with just a click of their Roku remote.

Bonus: we’re gifting you $5K in ad credits when you spend your first $5K on Roku Ads Manager. Just sign up and use code GET5K. Terms apply.

Use code GET5K now

CrowdStrike's story isn't just about cybersecurity—it's about whether AI hype justifies paying 125 times future profits.

The big question: Is this the essential platform protecting the AI revolution—or a dangerously overpriced stock ignoring fundamental risks?

Morgan Stanley Analyst (Major Investment Bank — Downgrade to Equal Weight): "We're raising our price target to $495 but downgrading to neutral. Shares ran up 50% since April, and the expected second-half acceleration is fully priced in. Long-term story remains compelling, but there's no value left at current levels."

Dair Sansyzbayev (9.6K Followers, Institutional Finance — Strong Buy): "Everyone's missing the AI transformation. CrowdStrike is investing heavily in R&D for agentic AI security—every AI agent needs protection. Conservative DCF shows double-digit upside. The Salesforce partnership and global expansion through Falcon create real competitive advantages."

Julian Lin (36K Followers, Growth Stock Expert — Sell): "The market's asleep on deceleration. Growth is slowing, and seat-based pricing limits AI upside versus usage-based competitors. At 28x sales, even optimistic projections imply minimal returns. Multiple compression is coming—find bargains elsewhere."

Parkev Tatevosian (CFA, Finance Professor — Hold): "I've held this position almost all year at hold. My DCF model shows intrinsic value at $299—the stock trades at $470. That's a forward P/E of 120x. Yes, they're a leader, but this is my least favorite cybersecurity stock purely on price."

Macquarie Research (Steve Koenig — Neutral, $485 Target): "The concern is simple: 20x enterprise value to revenue is pretty rich. They need time to grow into this valuation. We're not bearish on the business—just realistic about what's already priced in."

Michael Del Monte (5.9K Followers, Buy-Side Analyst — Buy): "Strategic acquisitions like Onum and Pangea are building an agentic AI moat. Every company deploying AI agents faces new attack surfaces. CrowdStrike's Charlotte AI platform makes security automated and intelligent. Financial flexibility supports continued innovation."

Yiannis Zourmpanos (12.6K Followers, Tech Pattern Spotter — Buy with Caution): "The Falcon Flex model is brilliant—over 75% utilization driving rapid upsells. Net new ARR is accelerating through platform consolidation. But revenue growth is slowing, and valuation leaves zero room for execution errors. One miss triggers a bloodbath."

Gary Alexander (32.5K Followers, Tech/Wall Street Veteran — Hold, Downgrade): "After that July outage, clients are hyperaware of update risks. Competition from Zscaler, Palo Alto, and SentinelOne is intensifying. Trading at 27x revenue and 148x P/E after a massive run-up? Time to take chips off the table until FY27 visibility improves."

Rogerio Adelino (CFA, Ex-CFO — Buy): "That incident was painful, but gross margins and growth remain intact. Cybersecurity is structurally expanding—attacks aren't decreasing. Post-incident, margins are recovering, and the company's positioned in an unavoidable business. Long-term potential justifies the premium."

Rick Orford (Trading Since 1999 — Bullish but Risky): "CrowdStrike has upside, but this isn't for risk-averse investors. They're innovating fast, moving toward profitability in an essential market. Just understand—at these valuations, you need a strong stomach for volatility."

Dhierin Bechai (Defense/Tech Analyst — Buy): "They crossed $1 billion in subscription revenue. That recurring revenue engine compounds as new client wins accelerate. There's still upside as the platform effect builds and cross-selling deepens."

The J Thesis (Institutional Asset Management — Hold): "Future looks bright, but the stock already knows it. Every positive catalyst is priced to perfection. Wait for a better entry unless you're buying for 5+ years."

The Business:

Valuation:

Bulls See:

Bears Warn:

I see CrowdStrike as the best business at the worst price.

The bull case is legitimate: they're the category leader, the AI security angle is real, and every company needs cybersecurity. The platform expansion and recurring revenue model work.

The bear case is math: you're paying 125x future earnings for a company posting losses with slowing growth. One guidance miss, another outage, or regulatory action sends this down 30% overnight.

My stance:

Bottom line: CrowdStrike could dominate AI security and reward patient investors—or teach everyone why valuation matters. The business is excellent, but excellent businesses become terrible investments at the wrong price.